ARRESTABLE Class C, though, correct? So they could make a custody arrest for the Class C misdemeanor, take the gun, force you to get magistrated, then go from there... if they wanted to be hard-nosed dicks. Some might, to make a point.
All depends on how much they've been drinking and how nicely you ask... or so I hear.
Take the gun which you'll never get back. Make sure that your EDC is a good hitter but nothing that would sit in your trophy case. I see so many that are walking around with a $2000 Kimber with their chest all pumped up all the while not thinking about a LEO could snatch that off and he'll never see his prized pony ever again.