Advice needed for 8-12 gun closet safe

[Skeezix]

I'm looking at several smaller safes that I can put in a closet. Space is at a premium, and the market is somewhat limited for safes of this size it seems. Below are the safes I'm considering, and hoping ya'll can provide feedback if possible as I'm looking to picking one up over the upcoming black Friday:

Winchester 12 gun at Tractor Supply: Not the highest quality, but size-wise should do the job:

https://www.tractorsupply.com/tsc/product/winchester-gun-safe-12-gun-ts12-30

Liberty Centurion 12: Looks about perfect and made in USA, but no shelf adjustment.

Centurion 12

The Centurion 12 is a space-conscious gun safe that comes with entry-level security features. The CN12 features 30 minutes of fire protection and a 14-gauge steel body.

www.libertysafe.com

ProVault 12: Same as Centurion 12, but in a different color

https://www.cabelas.com/shop/en/provault-12-gun-safe-by-liberty-with-electronic-lock

Tracker 8 gun safe: Imported, but has floor to ceiling adjustable shelves

https://www.tractorsupply.com/tsc/product/tracker-safe-8-gun-safe-electronic-lock-30-minute-fire-rated-ts08-esr-gry

Thanks in advance

 

[lightflyer1]

Just understand you will never get 12 guns (rifles) in there unless they are just jammed in

 

[Maverick44]

Just understand you will never get 12 guns (rifles) in there unless they are just jammed in

He might be able to get 12 rifles in there, but only if they're all Winchester lever actions, and only if none of them have scopes.

Whatever you get, bolt it to the floor and try to keep the sides unexposed.

 

[Skeezix]

For clarification this is a backup safe I’m hoping to get 5 long guns in or less. I’m well aware I can’t get 12 guns in a 12 gun safe.

I’m more interested to see if folks have any feedback about the safes I listed or any others I have missed.

 

[MountainGirl]

For clarification this is a backup safe I’m hoping to get 5 long guns in or less. I’m well aware I can’t get 12 guns in a 12 gun safe.

I’m more interested to see if folks have any feedback about the safes I listed or any others I have missed.

All I know about Liberty - is they gave an FBI agent the combo/access to a private citizen's safe over the phone (no warrant).

Safe companies giving police access to your personal safe - Liberty Safe - POLL

www.texasguntalk.com

 

[toddnjoyce]

If space was a premium, I'd be looking at the Stack-On steel cabinets instead.

 

[Skeezix]

If space was a premium, I'd be looking at the Stack-On steel cabinets instead.

Understand- was hoping for a little protection than a cabinet offers. Being as I only need space for 5/6 long guns I thought the safes I listed would suffice well.

 

[Tnhawk]

All I know about Liberty - is they gave an FBI agent the combo/access to a private citizen's safe over the phone (no warrant).

Safe companies giving police access to your personal safe - Liberty Safe - POLL

www.texasguntalk.com

I've had a small Liberty safe in a closet in my memphis house. As an older safe, it was made before the electronic locks were used. It has never failed, as have my newer Cannon electronic safes.