Hey, yes, I think so, similar premise. I have these EGW undersize decapping dies in 9, 40, and 45, and I just always reload 40 and 45 using an undersize decapping die. I use crappy, stepped on, dirty range brass. I swear by these EGW dies. I have read the risk is you stress the brass by the slight add'l squeeze, but I have never has issues with brass failure.